Badendochs Faith and the Value of Prayer

Letter Published in the Times 11 August 2025

I am somewhat envious of AN Wilson (9 August) and the certainties of all those who have faith. But Kemi Badenoch is not alone in having her prayers go unanswered.
One learns from early childhood not to expect very much in return for dutiful prayer. An omnipotent, all knowing and omnnipresent God should be a source of comfort , but the caveat is that God works in mysterious ways, that we cannot hope to understand .Neither can we hope to change the will of God through prayer.

Rabbi Jonathan Romain tells us that although prayer cannot alter our situations , it can change us.
On the latter claim he is surely right- I have changed from a believer ,into an agnostic!

Yours Sincerely

Patrick Watson

Americas Trump Revolution -Hubris followed by?

Trump has started a revolution. He is busy disrupting internal and external american politics, establishing a new order, he hopes, in which nothing is the same as it was, and never will be again, Conservative politics is about incremental change, about stability, about continuity, about preserving essential institutions that have stood the test of time, while modernising those that need to change. Its about building consensus , while preserving core values that inform policies. So, he is not a conservative. (Nor is the Republican party any more.) Nor is he an ideologue. He is a right wing autocrat, albeit an elected one, seeking to shape everything around him to serve his will, whimsical, or otherwise , informed by his worldview. A populist , and a nativist who believes, I think sincerely, that americans have been betrayed by liberal lefties and the wokerati. He is a Manichean,. Politics to his mind, is a matter of right and wrong. No shades of grey. You are either fully part of the project or you are an enemy.

The narrative is that Foreigners have been exploiting America and taking advantage of her generous spirit . They have been freeloading, on the back of american taxpayers , in defence , among other areas. . This must be corrected . America has lost its way and he knows how to get it back on track. Many americans , do buy into this vision. and there are elements of Trumps worldview that are obviously true. For example, Europe has ,to a considerable degree, been freeloading on defence, expecting america to constantly provide a security blanket mainly at american taxpayers expense. The British government is among the worst offenders when it comes to ensuring that we play a full part in NATO and meet our obligations. The British army no longer has the capability of deploying a fully supported mechanised division abroad, and, frankly would be hard pressed to maintain a notional 10,000 peacekeeping force for a sustained period in Ukraine.

To help Trump in his revolution, he is using the playbook represented in the Presidential Transition Project 2025, published by the right wing Heritage Foundations. He has surrounded himself with a motley collection of advisers, many of whom have been critics of his in the past, and none of whom are remotely qualified or sufficiently experienced for the tasks they have been given ,as recent events have painfully shown. The Trump administration is no meritocracy. It is tribal in nature. It elevates loyalty to the tribe and to Trump above all else- including experience, competence and skill.

Unlike President Lincoln, (probably Americas finest President), who liked to have his opponents close to him, even in cabinet, Trump wants a bunch of extremely mediocre ‘yes’ men, and lickspittles who simply deliver for him, rather that advise. And the delivery bit , as we have seen, is not going too well at the moment!

However ,when it comes to revolutions, the trouble with them, is that they have an annoying habit of gaining their own momentum, and spiralling out of control. Revolutions tend to eat their own, spitting them out. This may well be the fate of Trump. It is easy to destroy, it takes no time at all . It is much more of a challenge to build, not least friendships and alliances, that America will always need.

Tariffs are big revolutionary disruptors. They distort the market and the price signals that match demand with supply . They increase costs, and are by nature inflationary. They certainly have an impact but like all revolutionary acts they come with unforeseen consequences. And they alter relationships between countries over the longer term, draining the reservoir of goodwill built over many years.

It is highly likely, and this is already happening in places, that there will be at least a partial boycott of all things American, and not just cars.. This will hugely benefit Chinas industry more broadly , and its motor industry in particular, which already dominates the worlds EV market . China, is beginning to look to many observers to be a lot more stable politically and economically and more reliable than the USA. While Trumps administration see China as the main enemy, and it is pivoting towards the East , it is still busy handing it most of the good cards in the pack, as it has done to Russia, over Ukraine As America insists on doubling down bad mouthing, threatening and humiliating its allies, the non-aligned countries will be making judgements now as to who to get closer to in the future. China or the USA?

Teslas value will plummet further. It has lost a third of its value since Trump was elected, and is no longer the largest EV manufacturer. The billionnaires who support Trump, including Musk, who is finding the world of politics and diplomacy rather colder than he anticipated , will be worth a lot less than they were. American workers will lose their jobs. Inflation will rise, growth will slow. Allies aplenty will be lost. The penny will drop eventually with US electors and investors who will feel it in their pockets. Markets hate the uncertainty personified in Trump. He will lose support, enough possibly, to lose control of Congress at the midterms in 2026. Then you are in impeachment territory. The judiciary is lining up to thwart DOGEs efforts ostensibly to cut public sector inefficiencies, and the slew of Executive Orders, will continue to invite legal challenges. . The Supreme Court is also much less pliable than Trump hoped for, despite him loading it in his favour in his first term through his appointments.

Trumps cavalier approach to the law, the economy and allies, combined with his mediocre executive team, mean that by the midterms, problems will have mounted . The administration will be fighting court action after court action. In all probability Trump will be fighting impeachment. And his current supporters will still be asking him why the economy is not growing in the way he promised it would? After Hubris, comes Nemesis?

Chagos Islands

Letter to the Times Published 8 February 2025

Sir, As you point out in your leading article (“Troppo”, Feb 6), it was the Tories who started negotiations with Mauritius in 2019 after a hostile International Court of Justice opinion, an error of judgment that has been compounded by the present administration. Every government has responsibilities for defence and security and in ensuring value for money. Handing over £9 billion or more of taxpayers’ money to Mauritius in a leaseback arrangement, for a strategically important territory, is just the latest example of perverse government decision-making that serves further to erode our international influence, waste taxpayers’ money and signal that we are, at best, an unreliable ally.
Patrick Watson
London SW8

The Education Secretary Phillipson – More Pragmatism, Less Ideology, Please!


Private Schools will be subject to VAT on their school fees from 1 January 2025. However, supplies of ‘closely related goods and services’ linked to education will continue to be exempt; e.g. school meals, stationery, books and transport. The supplies must be for the direct use of pupils and necessary for delivering their education.
As well as charging VAT on the main school fees and boarding charges, private schools must also charge VAT on additional education provided to pupils, as well as fees for out of hours activities and school holiday clubs. Vocational training supplied by private schools will also be subject to VAT, defined as ‘all training, retraining or work experience or volunteer work in some cases’.
However the Government, and in particular the Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson, may have badly miscalculated . Experts say that there are practical and political advantages to delaying the implementation of this measure. A vital element of political decision making is managing risk. A delay would significantly reduce the risk of chaotic implementation, while the political downsides in delaying the measure are hard to see.
There are warnings from unions, tax experts and school leaders that meeting the deadline will cause administrative chaos and teacher job losses, and put undue pressure on the state sector.
They urge delay until next September (2025) to give private schools more time to register for the new tax, assess the impact and adapt accordingly.
There are also concerns about the effect on the special educational needs and disabilities (Send) sector if more state schools have to carry out Send assessments on pupils moving over from private schools. The NASUWT Union suggests that an impact assessment should be carried out on the possible increase in Send assessments in the state sector and the level of provision needed. The Union added “ We request that a more reasonable timeframe is proposed in order to implement the change fairly and without excessive disruption for teachers, pupils and parents.”

The Association of Taxation Technicians warned “The proposed commencement date of 1 January does not give sufficient time for schools or HMRC to adequately prepare and deliver the proposed changes. Commencing partway through an academic year could also introduce additional difficulties for schools and pupils. Consideration should be given to deferring commencement to September 2025.”

The Education Secretary has decided to put her Class Warrior hat on, shedding light on her motivations for raising VAT on school fees. In an unnecessarily provocative recent tweet , rubbing salt into the independent sectors wounds, she said “Our state schools need teachers more than private schools need embossed stationery. Our children need mental health support more than private schools need new pools. Our students need careers advice more than private schools need AstroTurf pitches”.

Most large private schools are in some form of partnership arrangement with a state school, or schools, not only sharing facilities , but also specialist teaching expertise and support. As well, of course, as offering full or partial bursaries to underprivileged pupils. So Phillipsons comments not only pour scorn on these on -going relationships but also signally fail to acknowledge the scale and scope of these efforts.

To be fair on Philippson she is learning on the job. She now needs to start listening and to understand that more is achieved in politics by taking stakeholders with you, and being pragmatic, rather than seeking unnecessary ideologically driven confrontations, that fuel resentment and , inevitably, come back to bite you!

Chinese Harrow -Letter to The Times

Published Letter 23 August 2024

Chinese Harrow
Sir, In his letter (Aug 22), the chairman of Harrow International School avoids addressing the concerns raised by Melanie Phillips (Aug 21) about how private schools, including Harrow, are able to square their values and what they are allowed to teach in the curriculum with the repressive ideology and propaganda of the Chinese Communist Party. The Chinese government elevates the party and collective rights over individual rights and freedoms, as evidenced by its human rights clampdown in Hong Kong. A new law introduced by the Chinese government in January requires that “all levels and types of school shall have patriotic education permeate the entire course of school education, doing a good job of ideology and political theory courses, and having patriotic education integrated into all subjects”.

What is the point in widening the access to education that Harrow claims is its socially progressive motivation if you cannot teach liberal values and are required to teach a curriculum dictated by the ideology and “patriotic” imperatives of a communist state?
Patrick Watson
London SW8

NIGEL FARAGE-PUTINS USEFUL IDIOT

Nigel Farage has argued that NATO and the EU , provoked Putins invasion of Ukraine through their eastward expansion .
Farage is no historian.
He is simply repeating tropes that have been integral to Putins propaganda narrative for many years , informed by his contested (contested, not least by the Ukrainians) assertion that Ukraine was, and is ,part of Greater Russia and the bogus claim that the West was behind Ukraines democratic decision to split from Russia.
Here is an awkward fact for Farage to chew on. In December 1994 the Budapest Memorandum on Security Assurances solidified international security commitments to Ukraine protecting Ukraines sovereignty . Signed by the United States, Russia, and the United Kingdom it was a political agreement in accordance with the principles of the Helsinki Accords,. The memorandum included clear security assurances against the threat or use of force against Ukraine’s territory or its political independence. The countries (including, remember, Russia!) promised to respect the sovereignty and existing borders of Ukraine. Parallel memorandums were signed for Belarus and Kazakhstan as well. In response, Ukraine officially acceded to the NPT as a non-nuclear weapon state on December 5, 1994. Russia, however then unilaterally breached that Accord!
Its an uncomfortable fact that NATO and the West had effectively ignored Moscow’s brutality in Chechnya and its provocative annexation of Georgian territory in 2008; Nor did NATO respond when Russia ,in breach of international law , occupied Crimea and invaded the Ukrainian Donbas region in 2014 claiming it was protecting Russian speakers ; Arguably NATO and the EUs failure to respond to these provocations, as well as its failure to respond to the atrocious behaviour of the Russian backed Assad regime in Syria (including its use of chemical weapons) and its mercenaries, set the scene for Putins invasion of Ukraine. So it can be plausibly argued that it was, in fact ,a lack of action by NATO, in challenging Russian provocations ,rather than the baseless claims of its eastward expansion , that provided the green light and motivation for Putin to invade Ukraine. All this was happening while NATO had never seriously contemplated admitting Ukraine as a member! (although one can entirely see why, against this backdrop of continuous Russian aggression ,Ukraine was urgently pressing for membership) .

Putin had spelled out his vision for a greater Russia on numerous occasions building on the narrative that Russias impoverished state, and its decline was due to the west. This played into Russias historical sense of victimhood blaming external players for its poor governance and economic decline.

The rich irony, of course, is that Putins invasion has spurred NATO into action as it rearms and has now welcomed in two new members , Sweden and Finland, who have seen straight through Putins (and Farages) baseless claims. #Farage #ukraine #Putinswar #ReformUK #PutinsWar

FREEDOM OF SPEECH AND RELIGION

Freedom of Speech like all Rights is not absolute. Its always been qualified.

But it has always been the case that faith leaders have demanded that people of faith should have a special, and uniquely privileged position, meriting protection from offence. People of faith they claim need to be protected from blasphemy , and from ‘hate speech’, a vague quasi -legal category that has confused many, not least our Police. .
The justification for freedom of speech is, broadly ,threefold. Firstly the pursuit of truth. In the marketplace of contested ideas and arguments the truth will be revealed. Its is worth recalling in this respect that JS Mill (in on Liberty) believed that the suppression of speech is not only detrimental when it suppresses valuable speech but also detrimental when it suppresses prejudices and falsities. Secondly, it is vital for democracy . Voters need access to objective information and arguments, in order to make informed choices and to hold their representatives to account . And, thirdly, personal autonomy and agency. Individuals must be allowed to make choices as to what they believe and how to act.
Many Faith leaders, of whatever persuasion, have a major problem with two of these justifications.Namely, a commitment to free inquiry and enabling individuals to make choices and to have agency.

Indeed the 18th Century Enlightenment was about the pursuit of truth and individual freedoms , removing the iron grip the men of faith had on our young peoples minds, through education and ‘ indoctrination’, specifically in our schools and universities, which at the time , broadly speaking ,they ran.


It is in the DNA of religious groups that they defend their group aggressively against perceived threats ,from both insiders and outsiders, who the group perceive as a threat. In this they have sought protection from the State. Blasphemy laws can be found in many countries, ostensibly to uphold the demands of public order but ,arguably , they are actually more about protecting the religious status quo, and its presiding hierarchy, from internal and external threats. These laws have no place in any liberal democracy. ,This does not prevent religious extremists invoking blasphemy to threaten, intimidate and coerce others.

It is the role of political leaders in a plural democracy to acknowledge that religious expression and action can both contribute to, but also fundamentally impede pluralism, and the rights of individuals and other interest groups. Where stands a democracy’s commitment to equality, if one group can demand special treatment and protection, from the exercise of freedom of speech and expression?

Lord Walney in his review ‘Protecting Democracy from Extremism’ 22 May is clearly aware that those responsible for protecting and upholding our rights need more clarity guidance and support in law to fulfil the most basic task of protecting freedom of speech from attack by illiberal political and religious activists, who believe their rights trump those of other citizens. They dont..

There is no right not to be offended in this country. No religion or belief system is immune from criticism, or exempted from our liberal democratic tradition. Blasphemy laws as the Review says are fundamentally incompatible with British values and principles.

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/government-strengthens-approach-to-counter-extremism#:~:text=But%20our%20democracy%20and%20our,the%20dangers%20posed%20by%20extremism.

Defence Weakness

Published Letter The Times 29 February

Sir, Your report (Feb 28) that Admiral Sir Tony Radakin has reprimanded General Sir Patrick Sanders for making a speech warning that the army was at risk of becoming static and domestically focused raises important points. It is a fact that the British Army can no longer deploy a fully supported mechanised division abroad. It is a concern to serving and retired officers that our politicians are failing in their duty to ensure that our army has sufficient resources to deter our enemies, secure our borders, assist the civil power in an emergency, support our allies and to honour our treaty obligations. The US has made its concerns about our diminished defence capabilities clear several times but with no substantive response from our ministers. There is little hope that next week’s budget will do anything but reinforce the fact that our politicians are in denial in failing to acknowledge or meet the new challenges we and our allies face, and the manifest implications this has for the resourcing of our armed services.
Patrick Watson
Former Black Watch officer

POST OFFICE SCANDAL-THE TYRANNY OF GROUPTHINK AND CONFIRMATION BIAS

There are are three standouts from the Post Office debacle.

Groupthink and confirmation bias are deeply embedded in the system. In short,  individuals , and indeed groups, look for evidence that supports their view ,or stance and either ignore arguments and evidence that undermines this, or afford it insufficient weight. They then become so invested in their view that to change it would be very damaging to them reputationally, and probably financially. They then aggressively defend positions that are wrong and unsustainable. As a former political lobbyist I clocked this years ago!

Third, and this is a new one on me, there is a presumption in common law that computer evidence is reliable. Indeed, Courts are directed to assume that a computer system has operated correctly, unless there is explicit evidence otherwise. This is complete nonsense on stilts and illogical. We all know that complex software is subject to bugs and glitches. Which is why , and how, hackers can access systems and steal information and data. They exploit programmers errors.

So why this presumption?

It has enabled a gross miscarriage of justice, on an industrial scale . While this is referred to as a  ’miscarriage of justice’ ,the term ‘perverting the course of justice’ seems rather more apposite. Post Office executives ,and their lawyers, knew of the glitches in the Horizon software yet chose to withhold, and not disclose this information , from the accused postmasters and the courts !

And, incredibly , programmers do not need any particular qualifications to practice. The law does not require anyone building computer systems to have any competence or qualifications.!

What could possibly go wrong?

THE NEED FOR MARTHAS LAW-WHY NHS TREATMENT AND CARE NEEDS FUNDAMENTAL REFORM.

I am recovering having just listened to Merone Mills on Radio 4 Today programme (around 7.40 this morning 4 September ) talking about the avoidable death of her 14 Year daughter, Martha, in an NHS specialist hospital. The most moving testimony I have heard in a long while. And of visceral importance too. Merone is lobbying for a new law ‘Marthas Law’ that gives a family the right to a second opinion if they are concerned about the diagnosis or treatment of their loved one in hospital. Martha had a minor bike accident that damaged her pancreas. If properly treated and monitored this should not have proved fatal. But negligence by NHS staff including senior consultants and duty doctors, meant that she got sepsis, which was then not diagnosed quick enough and she should have been put in intensive care before it was too late. Merone knew that her daughter was very seriously ill and probably had sepsis but was ignored or patronised by staff. She felt impotent with no agency. She deconstructs many of the problems endemic to the NHS ,experienced by many of us who have watched someone close to us die and been at the interface between NHS critical care and families.. Its important to point out that, generally, if it is an immediate obvious emergency the NHS generally is very good. And life saving. But too often after that initial emergency help the quality of treatment and care falls off a cliff..
Merone said that the hierarchy in which senior doctors opinions are never challenged is a huge issue. Doctors get it wrong and family members issues and concerns are ignored. True. You have no agency and there is no transparency or real accountability.
I remember from my experience at Kingston Hospital family visiting hours were arranged after Doctors and Consultants did their rounds, so as to avoid it, seems any contact with the family who couldnt be briefed and ask questions about the on-going treatment . We as it happens simply ignored visiting hours in order to get daily access to doctors
The NHS operates in silos. And this is the second problem. Nobody has ownership of the patients case. There is no one person you can talk to (if you can get access which often you cant )
who can give you chapter and verse on the treatment and prognosis. My experience is that they have very little time for you. And every day you see a different doctor , some more assiduous at reading notes than others. I remember challenging doctors three or four times saying you know he has already had that, or youve done that test already etc.. They dont seem to talk to each other in the way you might expect leading to a lack of continuity and inevitably a series of mistakes.
Third and many people seem unaware of this, as Merone pointed out , the NHS doest provide the same quality of treatment and care 7 days a week. The care noticeably drops off at Weekends and Bank Holidays. Those tests you think are vital wont happen on a Sunday or Bank Holiday Monday And that Doctor you spoke to on Friday wont be there or Saturday, nor will any other Doctor. To me this is quite staggering and unbelievable. Consultants as part of their contract can opt out of weekend work. God help you if something goes wrong at a weekend! This is the NHS in the 21st Century.
Last but no means least, which we have touched on already, if you have real concerns and worries there is nobody to talk to. You are patronised fobbed off avoided. If you break the rules and are there when the Doctor comes round, some treat you with contempt, others will give you 30 seconds before they march down the corridor with you in pursuit. You have no agency as concerned relatives. You cant challenge them or even alert them to an issue of concern. They and their opinions are sacrosanct. But they get things wrong, as do the nurses, (my god they do) and quite often the family are the only people who notice the sins of commission and omission because they are there day in day out (and yes at weekends) observing questioning and indeed caring . That is why the NHS needs fundamental operational reform. In the meantime we should support #marthaslaw #MeroneMills #NHS #nhsreform #demos